It’s a quote from the past that suddenly feels incredibly relevant again for Liverpool, as James Pearce revisited comments made by John W Henry during a previous moment of crisis at the club.
DOWNLOAD THE OFFICIAL EMPIRE OF THE KOP APP FOR ALL THE LATEST & BREAKING UPDATES – STRAIGHT TO YOUR PHONE! ON APPLE & GOOGLE PLAY
Writing for The Athletic, Pearce took us back to 2012, when Fenway Sports Group made the call to sack Kenny Dalglish despite domestic cup success, and the reasoning behind that decision now casts a long shadow over what we’re currently witnessing.
Henry’s Liverpool stance resurfaces after collapse
Speaking at the time, the Liverpool owner made it clear that silverware alone wasn’t enough if the overall trajectory of the team wasn’t right.
He said: “The FA Cup would not have made any difference had he won it. I think it was obvious to every Liverpool fan that something was wrong and something needed to be done.”
That line will hit home for many supporters right now, because while the FA Cup exit itself may not define Arne Slot’s future, the manner of the defeat absolutely does.
Pearce explains that the club’s priorities have remained consistent over the years, with Champions League qualification viewed as far more important than domestic cup success due to the financial and sporting implications.
Why Liverpool’s current situation feels familiar
The Athletic journalist makes it clear that this latest defeat is significant not because we’re out of the competition, but because of how it happened.
He wrote: “Winning the FA Cup would not have saved Arne Slot’s job this summer… however, it is the manner of the humiliating 4-0 quarter-final defeat… that should set alarm bells ringing on both sides of the Atlantic.”
That performance has amplified concerns that were already building, especially with the team collapsing after half-time and looking devoid of confidence.
Those fears have been echoed elsewhere, with John Aldridge admitting he’s worried about facing PSG, while Danny Murphy warned that recent displays are creating negativity around the squad.
When you put it all together, the message from FSG’s past and Liverpool’s present feels aligned, because it’s not just about results anymore, it’s about whether this team still looks like one heading in the right direction.
This team was incredible when Slot took over. In 16 months he alone has placed the team in a very vulnerable position and one which would not have happened under Jurgen Klopp. When fans start booing and leaving the stands, it shows they have lost all faith after the results of late, and we have never witnessed that at LFC
I think it’s time to get rid of Slot as he won the league last season with Klopp’s team. This was the season to prove himself with his new team and has failed. There is no fluency and the players don’t seem to have the belief this season. A few great performances isn’t enough for Liverpool and they have failed to live up to the transfer fees spent. We all miss Jota but it has been a time to recover and we have not performed enough. Why did we lose Luis Diaz as he was one of the best players last season? Just too many mishaps with Slot..
Slot has failed to leave up to the expectations. Slot took over the team from Klopstock and continued playing the same team and tactics that were applied by the previous manager who played players in their natural position and won the league with 4 games to spare. Slot started his dirty tactics changing players positions, selling Lewis Diaz instead of giving Diaz the pay he wanted he sold him. Slot should be be fired. Keeping him is destroying Liverpool and its supporters.
What pains me most is the way they decided to remain with gakpo and sold Diaz yet the same club first desired to make the transfer for Cody gakpo.
Secondly I wonder how they came to the conclusion that they well quansah and fails to make the deal for guehi just to wait for the last minute and eventually failed to pursue the deal.shame upon them
Selling Luis Diaz was one of the worst decisions by the club, but keeping Cody Gakpo maybe just a Dutch thing.
In normal circumstances Arno slot would have been fired long time ago given the fact that he absolutely does not know how to manage players and make changes to see results like how the previous managers did. His comments are weak and lack accountability. But Fsg is about business. Nothing else otherwise if American owners were worried after 4 losses in a row they would have done something. They didn’t. It’s how much of money they gonna make even if they lose the facup and league cup. Doesn’t matter. The fans make the club who it is. Why we lost to man city. Pep Leinders is the master and genius who we let go. We losing players that brought us success.
Bring in a, coach who knows Liverpool. Not someone we never heard about