An honest but eye-catching claim from Jamie Carragher has sparked debate among Liverpool supporters after the former defender backed himself to feature in the club’s modern side.
DOWNLOAD THE OFFICIAL EMPIRE OF THE KOP APP FOR ALL THE LATEST & BREAKING UPDATES – STRAIGHT TO YOUR PHONE! ON APPLE & GOOGLE PLAY
The Bootle-born pundit has built a reputation for strong opinions since retiring, but this time he’s turned the focus on his own playing ability and how it would translate into today’s game at Anfield.
Speaking on Zac Djellab on YouTube, the 48-year-old addressed how he’s viewed as both a player and a pundit before making a bold statement about his place in our team.
Carragher backs himself alongside Van Dijk
Reflecting on his legacy, the ex-No.23 said: “I’ve said this before I didn’t want to just be remembered as a player. I want to have an a life after that.”
But it was what followed that will really grab attention from us as Liverpool fans.
“But in terms of centre back, I’d be in Liverpool’s team even under Jurgen Klopp. That to me doesn’t mean that’s true.”
The former England international made it clear that his thinking comes down to one key question, particularly when considering the level we’ve seen in recent years.
“The way I look at it is, could I have played next to Virgil van Dijk who is for me the best centre back in the Premier League.”
That’s a significant statement given the Dutchman’s dominance, something Carragher himself has consistently praised, even describing him as the best centre-back the league has seen.
Comparing eras and centre-back demands
The Liverpool legend went further by comparing defensive partnerships across eras, suggesting adaptability is key when judging players.
“Could I have played there? Not a problem. Could they have played? Could Gomez, Matip and Konate played in the team I played in and done what I did?”
It’s a fascinating debate because it highlights how different tactical demands have become, especially when comparing the Rafa Benitez era to the high-line system used under Jurgen Klopp.
Carragher’s confidence shouldn’t come as a surprise given his 737 appearances for us, but it does underline a wider point about how his defensive intelligence and leadership might still translate into today’s setup.
Whether you agree or not, it’s another reminder that his legacy at Liverpool is often underrated when discussions turn to the very best centre-backs we’ve had.
I’ve been lucky enough to see most of the best centre backs who have played for Liverpool, so in all humility I’ll give my opinion who’s been the best and why.
I’ll also say who’s been the best in the premier league.
In life nothing stands still, human beings get faster stronger, more athletic ect. Through our history at Liverpool we’ve had great player’s at central defence.
Ron Yeats, Tommy Smith, Thompson, Lawrenson, hyppia and Hansen.
But none of these compare to the modern central defender. The best we’ve seen is van dijk.
Who’s got everything. Pace, physical strength, scores goals, and brilliant at passing the ball out of defence.
How many central defenders do you see who can spray 60 yard diagonal passes with accuracy out from the back.
Van dyke is also the best centre back we’ve ever had in the premier league, better than John Terry and the rest.
Finally you must also look at the style of football we played under klopp with van dijk. High risk, very high line, John Terry played defensive football, with coaches like Mourinho who were cautious. Much harder to defend paying the klopp system.
You never saw John Terry playing out of defence because he couldn’t pass the ball.
The same reason Jamie carragher will never be remembered as a great Liverpool defender, even with all his games. Carragher would have never coped under a klopp system with a high line, carragher had no pace, and he couldn’t pass the ball either.
Carragher was lucky at Liverpool, he had hyppia, and he was under houllier and benitez who were defensive coaches who had 11 players in defence.
Carragher was Never good enough to play modern football with a high line to pass the ball out of defence. He was an old school defender with no pace, he wasn’t the in the AIR. I remember a game carragher played for England against USA, where he got absolutely ripped apart.
So van dijk is the best ever at Liverpool and in the premier league history
The complete central defender. Fast, brilliant in the air, can pass as good as a midfielder, and can score
goals, reads the game as well.
Carragher would be lucky to get in the worst 100 Liverpool centre backs. I’ve seen quicker snails.